Verified Slice Customer
Consistently good food and service
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store.
Cheese Louise Pizza
$13.19
Out of stock
Keeping it original with mozzarella & our signature pizza sauce.
Single Hit Wings
$16.79
Out of stock
Old School Garlic Knots
$4.20
Out of stock
Pizza dough tied in a knot and brushed with olive oil, fresh garlic, and spices. served with marinara sauce.
Totally Cheesy Knots
$5.99
Out of stock
Garlic knots smothered in mozzarella cheese.
Manhattan Meatballs
$9.00
Out of stock
Covered in marinara, parm & parsley.
Ziggy’s Favorite Za Pizza
$16.20
Out of stock
Pepperoni, sausage, sauce, mozzarella & fresh basil.
Wiseguy’s Choice Pizza
$16.20
Out of stock
Pick any 3 toppings & we’ll build it for ya.
Our signature, NY-style thin-crust pizzas.
Cheese Louise Pizza
$13.19
Out of stock
Keeping it original with mozzarella & our signature pizza sauce.
Da Midtown Meltdown Pizza
$16.79
Out of stock
Extra pepperoni & extra cheese.
Margarita Village Pizza
$15.59
Out of stock
Olive oil, garlic, pizza sauce, tomatoes, fresh basil & mozzarella.
It’s All Greek To Me Pizza
$16.79
Out of stock
Garlic, feta & mozzarella cheese, sauce, fresh tomatoes, spinach, red onion, olive oil & topped with kalamata olives. Opa
Hawaiian Vacation Pizza
$16.79
Out of stock
Smoked ham, pineapple, sauce, mozzarella & fresh basil.
The Godfather Pizza
$16.79
Out of stock
Garlic, ham, pepperoni, salami, mozzarella, sauce, pepperoncinis, olive oil & fresh basil.
5 Boroughs BBQ Chicken Pizza
$16.79
Out of stock
Garlic & oil, bbq sauce, mozzarella, red onions, parsley & of course, chicken.
Whitestone Bridge Pizza
$16.79
Out of stock
Our “white” pie with fresh garlic, ricotta cheese, mozzarella, fresh spinach, olive oil & tomatoes.
Madison Square Garden Pizza
$16.20
Out of stock
Tomatoes, green peppers, onion, sauce, mozzarella, black olives & mushrooms.
Ziggy’s Favorite Za Pizza
$16.20
Out of stock
Pepperoni, sausage, sauce, mozzarella & fresh basil.
Wiseguy’s Choice Pizza
$16.20
Out of stock
Pick any 3 toppings & we’ll build it for ya.
Melting Pot Pizza
$16.79
Out of stock
Pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, sauce, mozzarella, ham & bacon.
The Big Apple Pizza
$16.79
Out of stock
Sausage, pepperoni, meatballs, green peppers, black olives, sauce, mozzarella, onions & mushrooms
The New Yorker Pizza
$16.79
Out of stock
Olive oil, garlic, sauce, mozzarella, eggplant, tomatoes & fresh basil.
Lasagna Pizza
$16.20
Out of stock
Pizza Sauce, Sliced meatball, ricotta, mozzarella, marinara, parmesan, parsley.
Mozzarella Sticks
$9.59
Out of stock
Old School Garlic Knots
$4.20
Out of stock
Pizza dough tied in a knot and brushed with olive oil, fresh garlic, and spices. served with marinara sauce.
Cheese Slice
$4.19
Out of stock
Totally Cheesy Knots
$5.99
Out of stock
Garlic knots smothered in mozzarella cheese.
Manhattan Meatballs
$9.00
Out of stock
Covered in marinara, parm & parsley.
Fried Raviol
$7.19
Out of stock
Basket Of French Fries
$5.99
Out of stock
Standard Antipasto Salad
$9.59
Out of stock
Genoa salami, ham, pepperoni, mozzarella cheese, red onions, peppers, tomatoes, olives, cucumbers, and pepperoncini on a bed of mixed lettuce with balsamic vinaigrette.
Jimmy The Greek Salad
$9.59
Out of stock
Mixed lettuce, feta cheese, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onion, green peppers, kalamata olives & pepperoncini.
Chop Salad
$9.59
Out of stock
Mixed lettuce, feta cheese, bacon, cucumbers, olives, tomatoes & served with our balsamic ranch dressing.
Traditional House Salad
$7.79
Out of stock
Mixed lettuce, tomato, cucumber, with black & green olives.
Hail Caesar Salad
$7.19
Out of stock
Romaine lettuce, croutons & grated parmesan cheese with Caesar dressing.
All served with marinara sauce.
Cheese Calzone
$13.19
Out of stock
Ricotta & mozzarella cheese.
Ham It Up Calzone
$16.79
Out of stock
Ricotta & mozzarella cheeses with lotsa thin sliced ham.
Little Italy Calzone
$16.79
Out of stock
Ricotta & mozzarella cheeses with pepperoni & sausage.
Tri State Calzone
$16.79
Out of stock
Ricotta & mozzarella cheeses with your choice of any 3 toppings.
City Slickers Calzone
$16.79
Out of stock
Ricotta & mozzarella with eggplant, tomato, mushrooms & fresh basil.
Daily News Stromboli
$16.79
Out of stock
Sausage, pepperoni & ham with mozzarella, rolled up like the daily newspaper.
Big sandwiches from the Big Apple. *Da works include lettuce, tomatoes, onions, oil, & vinegar, salt & pepper. On a low-carb diet? Order it without the bread!
The Mayor's Meatball Parmesan Sandwich
$15.59
Out of stock
Meatballs, marinara sauce, parmesan & mozzarella.
Chelsea Chicken Parmesan Sandwich
$16.79
Out of stock
Breaded chicken cutlet, marinara sauce, parmesan & mozzarella.
Goodfella's Eggplant Parmesan Sandwich
$16.79
Out of stock
Breaded eggplant, marinara sauce, parmesan & mozzarella.
Long Island BLT Sandwich
$14.39
Out of stock
Bacon, lettuce & tomato with mayo, oil, vinegar & black pepper.
The Italian Job Sandwich
$15.59
Out of stock
Genoa salami, ham, pepperoni, provolone, cheese, spicy mustard & da works*. Da works includes lettuce, tomatoes, onions, oil, vinegar, salt & pepper.
City Hall Chicken Sandwich
$16.79
Out of stock
Crispy chicken cutlet, mayo & da works*. Da works includes lettuce, tomatoes, onions, oil, vinegar, salt & pepper.
Steve-O-Rino Sandwich
$16.79
Out of stock
Half meatball parm, half chicken parm.
Just like being in Little Italy. "I'll make you a pasta you can't refuse."
Sonny's Spaghetti
$16.79
Out of stock
A generous portion of meatballs with spaghetti & marinara sauce.
Bensonhurst Baked Ziti
$17.99
Out of stock
Penne pasta, ricotta cheese, our signature marinara sauce, Parmesan & mozzarella cheese.
Grandma's Chicken Parmesan
$20.39
Out of stock
Breaded chicken cutlet, our signature marinara sauce, Parmesan & mozzarella cheese. Served with penne pasta.
Mama Leone's Eggplant
$20.39
Out of stock
Breaded eggplant, our signature marinara sauce, Parmesan & mozzarella cheese. Served with penne pasta.
Cheese Ravioli Dinner
$13.19
Out of stock
Our signature marinara sauce, parmesan & parsley.
Ravioli & Meatballs
$16.79
Out of stock
Our signature marinara sauce, meatballs, parmesan and parsley
Served with a soft drink & 3 garlic knots.
Kid's Arron's Pasta
$7.79
Out of stock
Penne pasta served with melted butter & a side of marinara sauce for dipping.
Kid's Eddie's Spaghetti & Meatball
$10.79
Out of stock
Kids' sized pasta with marinara and one meatball.
Kid's Chicken Strips
$11.99
Out of stock
Breaded n' fried, served with a side of ranch dressing.
Worth saving room for. "leave the gun...grab da cannolis."
14" pizzas.
Standard Antipasto Salad Catering
$58.20
Out of stock
Genoa salami, ham, pepperoni, mozzarella cheese, red onions, peppers, tomatoes, olives, cucumbers, and pepperoncini on a bed of mixed lettuce with balsamic vinaigrette.
Jimmy The Greek Salad Catering
$47.40
Out of stock
Mixed lettuce, feta cheese, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onion, green peppers, kalamata olives & pepperoncini.
Chop Salad Catering
$47.40
Out of stock
Mixed lettuce, feta cheese, bacon, cucumbers, olives, tomatoes & served with our balsamic ranch dressing.
Traditional House Salad Catering
$35.99
Out of stock
Mixed lettuce, tomato, cucumber, with black & green olives.
Hail Caesar Salad Catering
$29.95
Out of stock
Romaine lettuce, croutons & grated parmesan cheese with Caesar dressing.
Sonny's Spaghetti Catering
$58.20
Out of stock
A generous portion of meatballs with spaghetti & marinara sauce.
Bensonhurst Baked Ziti Catering
$58.20
Out of stock
Penne pasta, ricotta cheese, our signature marinara sauce, Parmesan & mozzarella cheese.
Grandma's Chicken Parmesan Catering
$69.60
Out of stock
Breaded chicken cutlet, our signature marinara sauce, Parmesan & mozzarella cheese. Pasta not included.
Mama Leone's Eggplant Catering
$65.99
Out of stock
Breaded eggplant, our signature marinara sauce, Parmesan & mozzarella cheese. Pasta not included.
Penne Marinara Catering
$35.99
Out of stock
What our customers are saying about Yo Pauly's New York Pizza Co.
Verified Slice Customer
Consistently good food and service
Chelsea J.
They were so helpful when the timing for my Order changed last minute.
